Jimmy Garoppolo Without Future in San Francisco
Kyle Shanahan and Jimmy Garoppolo talked on Tuesday, but Garoppolo is not practicing this summer. Garoppolo is the 49ers’ new backup quarterback, and there are rumors that Garoppolo will be traded to the Texans or released to the Seahawks. If that happens, we’ll have to wait until September before we can find out what happens next.
There’s no way to predict who will start the next game for the 49ers, but it appears that Jimmy Garoppolo and Trey Lance will be benched. While Garoppolo led the 49ers to the Super Bowl, Lance has a lackluster history as a starting quarterback in the NFL. If Lance is benched, the 49ers will likely turn to Kyler Murray or Derek Carr.
If the 49ers release Garoppolo now, that’s a good thing for the team’s young quarterbacks. The 49ers didn’t wait long to release Garoppolo, and now that he’s gone, they’ve made it clear that they don’t have a future in San Francisco. They’ll be building around 2021 first-round pick Trey Lance, but Garoppolo has no future in San Francisco.
While the team’s shaky draft process hasn’t produced any clear-cut answers, the 49ers’ recent decisions make it clear that they’ve moved on from Garoppolo. The third overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft, Lance earned a 90.7 PFF grade during his last full season as a starter at North Dakota State. His turnover rate was 1.3%. Lance played five games last season, starting two. He completed 41-of-71 passes for 603 yards with five touchdowns and two interceptions.
The San Francisco 49ers will not require Trey Lance and Jimmy Garoppolo to attend mandatory minicamp. The team will instead use a three-day workout schedule to replace the final week of organized team activities. Both quarterbacks have reportedly requested trades, so they will not be able to participate in camp. Whether they stay or leave depends on Kyle Shanahan’s decision.
With the 49ers looking to move on from Jimmy G, the question remains, “Is he too good to stay?” A report from NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport suggests the team plans to trade Garoppolo during the offseason to free up cap space and prepare for a possible replacement for Lance. If the 49ers are interested in trading Jimmy G, the season in Dallas is the final audition.
With the quarterback’s price tag in the range of $25 million to $29 million, other teams may be eager to sign him to a long-term deal. The Niners could decide to let him sit out the rest of the season, or even trade him. If they move on from Garoppolo, though, they will lose the draft capital they lost on Lance. The 49ers can use the extra cap space to get a quarterback they can use to improve their offense and draft a younger QB in the future.
The 49ers have made clear that they don’t have a clear answer to the question of whether Jimmy Garoppolo will stay in San Francisco. Although he has a salary-cap hit of $27 million for next season, the 49ers have stated that they aren’t about to give him away for free. They’d rather not have a quarterback controversy in 2021. So, who should be the quarterback for the 49ers?
With Trey Burton and Jimmy Garoppolo’s future uncertain, is this the time to trade them? Some analysts think so, and so does the coach. Both quarterbacks have dead money pending after 2020 and could be cut this offseason. The 49ers also have outs in the following two years. With both of these players coming off season ankle injuries, they may want to look elsewhere for their quarterbacks.
With the Bears, Burton and Garoppolo’s chemistry may have been the stumbling blocks. Burton signed a four-year, $32 million contract in March and started all 16 games for Chicago. He had 54 catches for 569 yards and six touchdowns, but he did not play the game’s wild card game against his former team. In the meantime, Burton has struggled through a variety of injuries.
The 49ers could use some help at tight end. They were interested in signing Austin Hooper before he signed with the Browns. Now, the 49ers have another chance to sign a free agent tight end, with the Bears releasing Trey Burton. Adding Trey Burton would give them a complementary piece to George Kittle. If they don’t sign Burton, they should go after another tight end.
If both George Kittle and Jimmy Garoppolo can’t play, the 49ers should consider benching one or both of them for the remainder of the season. The 49ers could benefit from a higher draft pick if they bench Jimmy Garoppolo and George Kittle. But it is too early to tell. The 49ers are already weakened on defense and offense and losing the first two games of the season isn’t enough to justify a move for Kittle.
Trey Burton’s progress
The 49ers have made it clear that they don’t have a quarterback in the first round of the draft, but they’re not completely ruling out trading Jimmy Garoppolo for a more experienced player. They’ve allowed Garoppolo’s agents to pursue commerce, and they’ve also addressed the pass-rush position with the signing of Samsom Ebukam. They also restructured Dee Ford’s contract to free up eleven million dollars on the cap. Although Garoppolo is not a sure thing, Lynch has cited several reasons why the team should consider Burton as the starter.
First, Garoppolo has a good track record in the red zone. He’s the third quarterback in his career to start with six wins in six starts, following Ben Roethlisberger and Marc Bulger. While Roethlisberger went on to win multiple Super Bowls, Bulger struggled to stay healthy and in a team that lacked talent.
The 49ers should avoid making any decisions based on injuries this week. If they decide to play with George Kittle, they’re better off sitting him for the rest of the season. The second reason they should sit Kittle is to protect the future of their offense. The 49ers need to be patient and protect their young stars. The 49ers have already lost a few key players to injury and are banged up on defense. While the lack of Kittle won’t affect the team’s season, it could affect their draft picks.
Trade for Garoppolo
Reports claiming that the 49ers will trade Jimmy Garoppolo for Lance Cook have been disputed. While some people are defending the move, others are pointing out the obvious. The emergence of Garoppolo has fueled speculation and rumors about the team’s future. But the 49ers aren’t about to move on from the franchise quarterback. It’s still possible that the team might consider trading Garoppolo for a new quarterback.
Even if a team is interested in a deal for a free agent quarterback, the Buccaneers may not need Garoppolo this year. They already have Tom Brady. They can also sign Jimmy Garoppolo as a free agent next year. In this scenario, the Buccaneers would receive a quarterback while still holding onto their franchise tag. Moreover, Garoppolo could end up signing with the Buccaneers even if the 49ers trade him.
The 49ers’ braintrust has done everything in their power to make a deal happen. The 49ers have given Garoppolo a cheap contract in 2022, and they’ve jumped up three spots to land the third overall pick. The 49ers also paid backup QB Nate Sudfeld $2 million fully guaranteed, and they hired a new QB coach to work with Lance.
There’s no way to justify retaining Jimmy Garoppolo when the 49ers don’t have any other quarterbacks on the roster. He’s already been a starter in three NFL seasons and was an admirable cog in the 49ers’ offense. He was a great locker room guy, supportive of teammates and coach, and even showed some grace in defeat. But retaining him now is not enough to win the Super Bowl.
The 49ers are in a situation they’ve created by retaining Garoppolo. Though it’s not clear what their long-term plans are for the quarterback, the offseason hiatus has made Jimmy Garoppolo a focus, and some prominent NFL reporters have speculated that the quarterback could stay on the team if the team is able to find a suitable replacement.
The salary cap is a factor, but it’s not as high as you might think. The salary cap doesn’t limit the salary of starting quarterbacks, so keeping Jimmy Garoppolo would not affect the rest of the roster. If you’re a reporter, it’s your job to let the audience know exactly what incentives you’re offering to Garoppolo.
Besides the offseason shoulder surgery, the 49ers tried to trade Garoppolo this offseason. However, the 49ers were unsuccessful, and Garoppolo was placed behind Trey Lance during his “swan song” year in San Francisco. The quarterback had shoulder surgery offseason and suffered an injury in the playoffs. Retaining Jimmy Garoppolo without future in San Francisco